Time for Western separation

[Nefarious Banana]

3 hours ago, cougar said:

Why not just move south where he will be your leader and you do not need to change anything?

You've threatened to move away/back to where you came from . . . what's holding you here?

[cougar]

29 minutes ago, Nefarious Banana said:

You've threatened to move away/back to where you came from . . . what's holding you here?

nothing.  just trying to figure out how soon I can get a pension and leave.

[blackbird]

7 hours ago, Barquentine said:

Renewables will outpace fossil fuels within 20 to 30 years and no one will want Alberta's dirty oil. What then? 

Afraid you're completely wrong.   The world is using more oil than ever and will continue to do so.  There is no such thing as renewables that could possibly replace fossil fuels for the foreseeable future.  We need fossil fuels for aircraft, deep sea shipping, passenger ships, and millions of motor vehicles, large trucks, and buses.  Only radical environmentalists live in the imaginary world of renewables. They don't have a clue about the real world.    How old are you anyway?

[Nefarious Banana]

14 minutes ago, cougar said:

nothing.  just trying to figure out how soon I can get a pension and leave.

Did you actually have a job in Canada?  Were you supported by Canadian taxpayers?

[cougar]

1 minute ago, Nefarious Banana said:

Did you actually have a job in Canada?  Were you supported by Canadian taxpayers?

No.  I have been supporting the likes of you.

[herbie]

If you don't believe in Canada you are free to pack up and leave for any country you think is better.
We'll be happy to revoke your citizenship and strike you off the voters list.

That's my view on "western separatism". Dissolve the Legislature and return any western province to territorial status if it tries.

[Nefarious Banana]

3 minutes ago, cougar said:

No.  I have been supporting the likes of you.

No, you didn't have a job?  How could you then support a working/self sufficient logger?  Why would you want to?

[cougar]

1 minute ago, Nefarious Banana said:

No, you didn't have a job?  How could you then support a working/self sufficient logger?  Why would you want to?

The "No" was to your second question.   

[Nefarious Banana]

7 minutes ago, cougar said:

The "No" was to your second question.   

Were you ever happy in Canada?  Have Canadians lived up to your expectations and standards?

[cougar]

Just now, Nefarious Banana said:

Were you ever happy in Canada?  Have Canadians lived up to your expectations and standards?

😂 Wow, you should be working for the statistics or customer relations branch at CIC, if they only had one.  But they know the general answers to the questions you asked and they are not eager to make it public.

[WestCanMan]

22 minutes ago, cougar said:

No.  I have been supporting the likes of you.

By "Fighting Economic Growth"? 

You said the quiet part out loud, Libbie.

Edited Wednesday at 11:24 PM by WestCanMan

[Nefarious Banana]

2 minutes ago, cougar said:

😂 Wow, you should be working for the statistics or customer relations branch at CIC, if they only had one.  But they know the general answers to the questions you asked and they are not eager to make it public.

The questions /inquiries were ment for you.  Just wondering why you continue to stay in north coast British Columbia if you're unhappy with Canada?

[cougar]

18 minutes ago, Nefarious Banana said:

The questions /inquiries were ment for you.  Just wondering why you continue to stay in north coast British Columbia if you're unhappy with Canada?

"Canada" is a word.  There is the social and economic environment ; then there is nature.  I am here for the latter.

[cougar]

28 minutes ago, WestCanMan said:

By "Fighting Economic Growth"? 

You said the quiet part out loud, Libbie.

actually the Libbies are too soft for me.  You would have had a really rough time if I was to have it my way.

[Nefarious Banana]

8 minutes ago, cougar said:

"Canada" is a word.  There is the social and economic environment ; then there is nature.  I am here for the latter.

You're there for the nature . . . and you're unhappy with Canada?  Where could/would you go to find nature like Canada has, and be happy too?

[cougar]

2 minutes ago, Nefarious Banana said:

You're there for the nature . . . and you're unhappy with Canada?  Where could/would you go to find nature like Canada has, and be happy too?

Can't elaborate too much.  Not in the mood for it.  No time.

[WestCanMan]

2 minutes ago, cougar said:

actually the Libbies are too soft for me.  You would have had a really rough time if I was to have it my way.

Libbies aren't exactly soft.

Libbies in the US did billions of dollars of damage to homes and businesses, assaulted and killed citizens, scalped a ret4rded kid, assaulted thousands of cops, and even assassinated cops. Some of their crimes were so serious that Kamala Harris couldn't get them out of jail, and the bail fund she promotes put killers on the street. 

After all that, our PM said that the BLM movement was a perfect example of the type of protest that he supports...

So all this time you could have been assaulting and killing people but instead you were just smearing your feces on Teslas and then licking the windows 😉

[Army Guy]

On 4/29/2025 at 7:58 PM, taxme said:

The Maritimes helped elect Corney to be the WEF leader of Canada. I say that the west should go and let all those lefty lieberal Maritimer's go to hell and freeze. They have shown to me that they are not Canadians. Only people who do not care about Canada would vote another WEF globalist dictator back in power.

 

Hey fruit cake, you do know that toronto has more seats than the entire atlantic provinces...along with most of the major city centers....if you have problems with math i'll help you...Atlantic canada has 32 seats,ontario has 122, Quebec...78 want to blame the liberal win on someone talk to those provinces...

https://www.ourcommons.ca/Members/en/party-standings

[WestCanMan]

1 hour ago, Army Guy said:

Hey fruit cake, you do know that toronto has more seats than the entire atlantic provinces...along with most of the major city centers....if you have problems with math i'll help you...Atlantic canada has 32 seats,ontario has 122, Quebec...78 want to blame the liberal win on someone talk to those provinces...

https://www.ourcommons.ca/Members/en/party-standings

The Atlantic provinces actually have way more voting clout than they should based on their population.

Some of them get about 1.4 votes compared to Albertans IIRC. I did the math on that during the 2021 election. 

[WestCanMan]

Left4rds, let's work together!

Let's face it: this election was probably a little too close for comfort for you guys...

Even with the help of the Chinese gov't, the help of Donald Trump, and a billion dollar bribe (taxpayer money of course) to the CBC, the CPC gained 25 seats and the Libs only gained 9.

When you take into consideration the fact that the Libs actually gained those 9 seats in Quebec, at the expense of the Bloc (-11), that means that basically all of the new CPC MP's across the rest of the country actually came at the expense of the NDP, and those were the most diehard left4rd voters before 2025.

To make matters worse, the CBC was using the "FEAR TRUMP" card on them when they all switched to the right. Just imagine leftists, the biggest sheeple on earth, ignoring the Fear Trump narrative. It's like jellyfish somehow swimming up over a waterfall.

That should scare you.

 

Bottom line: with the help of China and Trump, a billion dollar bribe to the CBC, and a sweet "fear Trump" narrative, the Libs only finished 25 seats ahead of the CPC, out of 343 ridings, and the CPC gathered a lot of support from people who used to be way to the left of intelligent.

So, 4 years from now, when the country is even worse off than it is now, will the CBC and China be able to drag the LPOC across the finish line again, with all that solid CPC support in AB and Sask?

Let's face it, if you guys really want 1-party rule, you need Alberta and Sask to separate. If that happens, it will be a cakewalk for the LPOC to win every election. You won't even need to bribe the CBC. 

 

TBH, this whole "Canada unity" message ends up with Alberta and Saskatchewan still in Canada. Is that really what you want? The wolf will always be at the door when the CPC win 95% of the ridings in those two provinces.

Left4rds: help us help you get to the promised land of 1-party rule. Let's all get together and make western separation a priority.

Can we at least do this one thing together?

Call your local MP and just let them know that you really thought this through, and in your heart of hearts, you really want those two gone. What's the worst that could happen?

[betsy]

On 4/28/2025 at 10:21 PM, West said:

Carney is a sick man who will now target the old lady's church land just like his hero Joe Biden

Ctv is a bunch of sickos. 

CBC is a joke 

Time to leave Canada and let Eastern Canadians continue to claim moral superiority as they get caught in scandal after scandal. 

Too many sickos down east

 

 

Just wondering, in case of separation..........how many Canadians will leave Alberta, and how many will actually move to Alberta?

That would be so interesting to know.

 

 

In a separation scenario - would Alberta welcome as many Canadians who live in other provinces, who'd want to move to Alberta,  and join?  

Your thoughts?

Edited 23 hours ago by betsy

[betsy]

A couple of years from now - as I've said in another thread - the issue of a referendum might pertain to all of CANADA.

 

Constitutional lawyer explains REFERENDUM changes and path to independence

 

 

Edited 23 hours ago by betsy

[betsy]

Alberta just opened the door to separation—and we’re done getting screwed

 

 

 

 

 

[Aristides]

We get this every time the Liberals win an election. Maybe wait and see what Carney does? Moe seems willing to give him a chance. Smith is just being Smith. 

[TreeBeard]

8 hours ago, betsy said:

In a separation scenario

Alberta has no inherent right to Canadian soil, including Canadian oil in that soil.   Canada gave Alberta jurisdiction over certain things, like resources, as a province of Canada.  

https://williamgairdner.ca/does-any-province-of-canada-have-a-right-to-separate/ The land-area now controlled by Alberta was recognized as falling under Alberta jurisdiction as a province of Canada, and not as a separate country.

[…]

Canada’s own Supreme Court, after the last Quebec debacle, issued an opinion that a UDI is not possible in Canada. To wit:

“the Constitution does not permit unilateral secession: Canada is a federal state based on constitutional government – and subject to the rule of law. The courts have a duty to uphold that Constitution – and to ensure that no level of government exceeds its powers. Secession would affect the structure and scope of that Constitution – so it would require constitutional amendments,”
 

Canada would have as much right to decide what lands belong to a nation called Alberta as Alberta does.  Canada would also have a duty to the citizens who voted against secession and wish to remain citizens of a province in Canada.

Alberta secession is just a fantasy.  A fantasy of an aggrieved few who aren’t mature enough to deal with not getting their way in politics   It’s pathetic.

 

2 hours ago, Aristides said:

We get this every time the Liberals win an election. Maybe wait and see what Carney does? Moe seems willing to give him a chance. Smith is just being Smith. 

Even if Carney fails as PM, there is no solution by seceding from Canada. 

Edited 14 hours ago by TreeBeard