Far left judge tries to overrule the Supreme Court

[West]

https://www.foxnews.com/politics/georgia-judge-overturns-states-six-week-heartbeat-abortion-law-calls-unconstitutional

Vile scumbag. These Marxists need to be eradicated from the bench quickly before they do more damage to the US. 

[TreeBeard]

What are the legal flaws in the judge’s ruling?

 

The judge was appointed by a Republican governor.  

Edited October 1, 2024 by TreeBeard

[CdnFox]

1 hour ago, West said:

https://www.foxnews.com/politics/georgia-judge-overturns-states-six-week-heartbeat-abortion-law-calls-unconstitutional

Vile scumbag. These Marxists need to be eradicated from the bench quickly before they do more damage to the US. 

It is judicial activism and that's a problem.  I happen to disagree with the heartbeat law as i feel the logic isn't good,  and i could see a judge saying that any law involving abortion is somehow unconstitutional under Georgia's constitution because "My body", although i disagree with that as well. 

But to argue that "its her body her choice"  because constitution of Georgia and THEN argue "BUT - i'ma go ahead and say it's NOT her right based on my personal interpretation of when someone becomes a human" is not only logically indefensible but also a completely arbitrary decision that the judge denied the state because their decision was a completely arbitrary one. 

either the state (and judges as a part of the state) have the legal right to determine when a fetus becomes a human and rights attached or they don't . The judge is an ass.

4 minutes ago, TreeBeard said:

What are the legal flaws in the judge’s ruling?

His premise is that the woman has the right to choose and therefore cannot be constrained, and then explains how he's got the power to constrain her. 

Its entirely flawed.  Either the state has that right in which case it's body appointed to make laws does or they do not in which case the judge does not. 

This is legal activism.  Who appointed the judge is not relevant. 

[West]

29 minutes ago, TreeBeard said:

What are the legal flaws in the judge’s ruling?

 

The judge was appointed by a Republican governor.  

Why does the baby have rights at 22 weeks but not 6? 

Also abortion isn't a constitutional right. Ridiculous argument 

Edited October 1, 2024 by West

[robosmith]

8 minutes ago, West said:

Why does the baby have rights at 22 weeks but not 6? 

Also abortion isn't a constitutional right. Ridiculous argument 

Freedom of the woman to control her body is based on the 4th amendment right to privacy.

Unless you have a vagina, it's NONE of YOUR BUSINESS cause you're NOT AFFECTED.

And you're a FOOL to believe the LIARS at FOS LIES. 🤮

Edited October 1, 2024 by robosmith

[West]

20 minutes ago, robosmith said:

Freedom of the woman to control her body is based on the 4th amendment right to privacy.

Unless you have a vagina, it's NONE of YOUR BUSINESS cause you're NOT AFFECTED.

And you're a FOOL to believe the LIARS at FOS LIES. 🤮

You are a disgrace

[robosmith]

23 minutes ago, West said:

You are a disgrace

You're the one who attempts to deny women's rights. 

[Rebound]

8 hours ago, West said:

https://www.foxnews.com/politics/georgia-judge-overturns-states-six-week-heartbeat-abortion-law-calls-unconstitutional

Vile scumbag. These Marxists need to be eradicated from the bench quickly before they do more damage to the US. 

Interesting. So opposing the SCOTUS makes someone a Marxist? Because the Georgia abortion ban was signed into law in 2019, when Roe v Wade was still in effect. So it is a Marxist law. 

Edited October 1, 2024 by Rebound

[CdnFox]

58 minutes ago, West said:

 

Also abortion isn't a constitutional right. Ridiculous argument 

Georgia has it's own constitution and he's trying to shoe horn it in under that one. 

50 minutes ago, robosmith said:

Freedom of the woman to control her body is based on the 4th amendment right to privacy.

She's welcome to control her own body. But not the body of the baby inside her once it reaches a point where it's a human being. 

THat should be obvious.  The issue is when does it become a human being.  But her right to her body does not include the right to kill children. Once the fetus is a person then her rights go out the window with respect to the infant. 

Edited October 1, 2024 by CdnFox

[Guest]

2 hours ago, CdnFox said:

She's welcome to control her own body.

There's a but coming up. Someone like you..I am willing to bet that.. 

2 hours ago, CdnFox said:

But

🤡

[Moonlight Graham]

2 hours ago, robosmith said:

Freedom of the woman to control her body is based on the 4th amendment right to privacy.

Unless you have a vagina, it's NONE of YOUR BUSINESS cause you're NOT AFFECTED.

And you're a FOOL to believe the LIARS at FOS LIES. 🤮

"Unless you're a German the holocaust is none of your business because you're NOT AFFECTED."

"Unless you're a slave owner then slavery is none of your business because you're NOT AFFECTED."

[Chrissy1979]

In my experience, most men who opposed abortion are rapists who feel threatened they will have no other chance to reproduce. This thread confirms that 

[CdnFox]

8 hours ago, Perspektiv said:

There's a but coming up. Someone like you..I am willing to bet that.. 

LOL that wasn't MY but kiddo, that was the judges but  

You have a weird fixation for buts. 

[CdnFox]

2 hours ago, Chrissy1979 said:

In my experience, most men who opposed abortion are rapists who feel threatened they will have no other chance to reproduce. This thread confirms that 

I suspect your "experience" with men is pretty much limited to playing with your ken doll as a kid before he rejected you and started dating your GI Joe.  Clearly it's left you emotionally scarred

 But i think it's hilarious that you're claiming you hang out with all these male rapists regularly  

[Chrissy1979]

It's here or Twitter and Twitter is even worse.

[I am Groot]

13 hours ago, West said:

https://www.foxnews.com/politics/georgia-judge-overturns-states-six-week-heartbeat-abortion-law-calls-unconstitutional

Vile scumbag. These Marxists need to be eradicated from the bench quickly before they do more damage to the US. 

All the Supreme Court said was that abortion was a state matter. So this Republican judge isn't overruling them at all. You don't seem to know anything about this issue.

[Nationalist]

2 hours ago, Chrissy1979 said:

In my experience, most men who opposed abortion are rapists who feel threatened they will have no other chance to reproduce. This thread confirms that 

You really are a dunce...

[I am Groot]

11 hours ago, West said:

Why does the baby have rights at 22 weeks but not 6? 

Also abortion isn't a constitutional right. Ridiculous argument 

He said an individual has a right to decide on their own healthcare according to the state's interpretation of 'liberty'.

Do you not believe individuals should have the right to decide their own healthcare? Are you against liberty?

Why do you lefties keep trying to impose the state's interest on individuals? We don't need any more of your big brother government! 

10 hours ago, CdnFox said:

Georgia has it's own constitution and he's trying to shoe horn it in under that one. 

She's welcome to control her own body. But not the body of the baby inside her once it reaches a point where it's a human being. 

The idea it is a human being after six weeks is insane.

[Chrissy1979]

5 minutes ago, Nationalist said:

You really are a dunce...

I'm sorry all your spawn were aborted, but it was the humane thing to do.

[Guest]

46 minutes ago, CdnFox said:

You have a weird fixation for buts. 

You have a fixation for stupidity. 

[robosmith]

8 hours ago, Moonlight Graham said:

"Unless you're a German the holocaust is none of your business because you're NOT AFFECTED."

"Unless you're a slave owner then slavery is none of your business because you're NOT AFFECTED."

^False equivalency FTL!

1. Jews all over Europe were affected, as well as their friends, and potentially all over the world.

2. Slaves were affected as well as their FAMILIES. Not to mention everyone who had to compete with free labor.

OTOH, natural miscarriages happen ALL THE TIME, and only the woman and perhaps her friends and family are the least bit affected.

You see, your analogies are INVALID for another reason: there is no conflict of rights in the examples you cited.

OTOH, a US citizen woman's right to make a free choice about whether a parasite should inhabit her body is a right in conflict with the fetus in her womb.

I don't expect you to acknowledge your CLEAR ERRORS of LOGIC.

 

[Guest]

44 minutes ago, CdnFox said:

But i think it's hilarious that you're claiming you hang out with all these male rapists regularly  

You're jealous what your father did to you, was consensual. 

[robosmith]

24 minutes ago, Nationalist said:

You really are a dunce...

You really are BANKRUPT.

[CdnFox]

1 hour ago, Chrissy1979 said:

It's here or Twitter and Twitter is even worse.

So in other words it's all in your imagination. 

Well to be honest i think we all knew that  

In my experience women who think like you eat babies. 

36 minutes ago, Perspektiv said:

You're jealous what your father did to you, was consensual. 

Oh look the leftie is sharing incest stories again   Every single one of you,,,,  do you have to have been raped as a child to be a leftie or something? She's got rape fantasies and you keep coming back to people's butts and incest.  Must mean SOMETHING!  

[Guest]

31 minutes ago, CdnFox said:

Oh look the leftie

Heh, funny how those who disagree with you, become lefties. 🤡