Where do Canadians stand on protecting the Jewish state of Israel?

[herbie]

1 hour ago, eyeball said:

Realistically, they should just peacefully purchase land from the Syrian or Egypt.

What a uniquely Trumpian attitude, buying other countries like it was 1867. And I thought 1953 was MAGAs dream era.

[paxamericana]

8 hours ago, herbie said:

What a uniquely Trumpian attitude, buying other countries like it was 1867. And I thought 1953 was MAGAs dream era.

??? I think you’ve tested positive for TDS. Israel’s housing crisis is not a Trump problem. He’s trying to solve it by getting rid of the squatters and developing the area for high end mall and high rises mmmkay.

Edited July 28, 2025 by paxamericana

[eyeball]

47 minutes ago, herbie said:

What a uniquely Trumpian attitude, buying other countries like it was 1867. And I thought 1953 was MAGAs dream era.

You meant to quote paxam I think. It was he who said Realistically, they should just peacefully purchase land from the Syrian or Egypt.

I suggested they should have been given a big piece of Germany. No purchase would have been necessary following the 2nd world war.

[Nationalist]

This Canadian has no love for Isreal. Let them fight their own wars.

[Moonlight Graham]

Most Palestinians and most Muslim leaders don't want a 2-state solution, they want a 1-state solution ruled by Muslims and the destruction of Israel, and this has been what they've wanted for the last 80 years.

The Canadian and France governments are fools.  They have incentivized the Oct 7 attacks and made further terrorist attacks more likely.  All a Palestinian state will do is give jihadists more of a platform to attack Israel from and more rights to import weapons to do so.   There will be no peace until Israel is destroyed.

The proper response from western countries is help defend Israel from their attackers while holding both Israel and Palestinian governments accountable to international law.

[Moonlight Graham]

2 hours ago, eyeball said:

You meant to quote paxam I think. It was he who said Realistically, they should just peacefully purchase land from the Syrian or Egypt.

I suggested they should have been given a big piece of Germany. No purchase would have been necessary following the 2nd world war.

What's the difference between giving Israel a piece of Mandatory Palestine vs a piece of Germany?   I doubt the native Germans would want to live in Israel on their own land as much as Palestinian Muslims don't.

Western allies + USSR defeated and occupied Germany after WWII, just like Western allies defeated and occupied the Ottoman Empire (including Palestine) after WWI.

[CdnFox]

18 hours ago, ExFlyer said:

Why should Canadian protect Israel??? They have killed far more Arabs and get praised for it??

Should Canadians not protect the innocents being killed by indiscriminate bombing by Israel? 

Really do not care what goes on in the Middle East. It has been a constant problem since State of Israel was thrust upon the world. Iran could nuke the entire region and it would not be missed.

11 million Jews died in the holocaust so your claim that they've killed more Palestinians is clearly false

And there are no innocent people being killed in gaza as near as we can tell and the bombing is not indiscriminate

As far as one state or two state or 10 state goes I really don't see why we would even have an opinion. What we think does not matter, the only thing that matters is what the people in that region will accept.

I don't really care what the solution looks like, I just hope that someday they can learn to live in peace and prosper. Whatever makes them happy is fine, but there will never be a solution of any type as long as one side has a policy that says all Jews Must Die. You just can't negotiate with that

[Barquentine]

20 hours ago, I am Groot said:

turned it into the richest, most powerful nation in the region

 It wasn't the Israelis who did that. It was American money. Still is.

On 7/27/2025 at 8:01 AM, blackbird said:

It should be a reminder of what can happen in the world we live in.

So one genocide justifies another?

[blackbird]

3 minutes ago, Barquentine said:

 It wasn't the Israelis who did that. It was American money. Still is.

So one genocide justifies another?

You call it that.  I am not going to be a judge.  A nation has the right to defend itself.  I don't know how you root out and eliminate the terrorists when they hide among the population.  Maybe you can tell us how it should be done.

[Barquentine]

9 minutes ago, blackbird said:

how you root out and eliminate the terrorists when they hide among the population.

By bombing hospitals, killing children and starving the entire population?

[paxamericana]

13 minutes ago, Barquentine said:

By bombing hospitals, killing children and starving the entire population?

Preferably you deport their entire population elsewhere , to like Canada. It’ll solve your demographic problem and you get to show the Israeli how to better treat a hostile terrorist population that sends love missile every month to a densely populated urban area . I see this as a complete win for everyone. 

[ExFlyer]

12 hours ago, WestCanMan said:

 

It's clear from you wrote there that everything that you know about Israel would fit in a nutshell and rattle.

I'll be honest: the existence of ancient Israel isn't of much significance, as far as I'm concerned.

Sure, truthfully it was preposterous that the whole region was named Palestine by the Romans, because that region was as "Palestinian" at that time as BC is part of PEI. I know that you don't have a clue what I mean by that, and it's not worth explaining to you.

.....

If Israel cedes that underground space to Hamas they will be incinerated, 100%. Israel itself is so small that just a couple nukes can wipe out all of their industry and the vast majority of their population. 

Blah blah blah.  LOSER in all aspects.

[ExFlyer]

9 hours ago, Army Guy said:

Not the UN but the league of nations, .

There are hundreds of posts with your name attached to it, on these very topics...

You said you Iran could nuke could nuke the entire area a.

 

....

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_foreign_policy_in_the_Middle_East

UN resolution 181.

Middle East 1920's 

You are incorrect. Only time I made comment was when I was addressed.

I never once said Iran should or could nuke Israel..  I said "

Your wiki is not about Israel.

I end with my opinion and stand by it but, some like you keep addressing me and I respond.

Again, I am not going. to argue with you...goodbye.

 

 

[eyeball]

8 hours ago, Moonlight Graham said:

What's the difference between giving Israel a piece of Mandatory Palestine vs a piece of Germany?   I doubt the native Germans would want to live in Israel on their own land as much as Palestinian Muslims don't.

Sure. That's why we should have welcomed them, instead we directed them to Palestine - the manner in which we did that as Canadians was really nothing less than an act of geopolitical vandalism. We effectively showed refugees how to colonize and dispossess indigenous people of their territories.

[CdnFox]

4 hours ago, Barquentine said:

 

So one genocide justifies another?

One genocide justifies defending yourself against a second genocide.

If Palestine laid down its arms and surrendered tomorrow, within a short number of years they would have their own nation. If Israel laid down its arms and surrendered tomorrow we would have a second holocaust

So yeah. What's happening is entirely justified. Gaza can stop it at any moment but chooses not to and chooses to continue after having provoked the war in the first place.

There's nothing wrong with putting down an aggressor.

1 hour ago, eyeball said:

Sure. That's why we should have welcomed them, instead we directed them to Palestine - the manner in which we did that as Canadians was really nothing less than an act of geopolitical vandalism. We effectively showed refugees how to colonize and dispossess indigenous people of their territories.

Too bad, it happened. Now it's up to the people in those regions to make it work. Israel was willing to make it work but Palestine wanted nothing less than the death of the Jews. They were unwilling to consider anything else.

That is their decision, it's not our decision, and they are living with the consequences. Or no longer living with the consequences as the case may be

[herbie]

.... buy it and deport 'the squatters' from their own land.... develop it into something 'useful', 'worthwhile'...

The attitude has not changed wince the days of the Wild West.

[eyeball]

1 hour ago, CdnFox said:

Too bad, it happened. Now it's up to the people in those regions to make it work. 

That is their decision, it's not our decision, and they are living with the consequences. Or no longer living with the consequences as the case may be

I'm pretty sure vandalism is a crime. The awful and long term damage and consequences of this should give pause to consider making things like the partition plan used to make way for colonization a crime against humanity.

We're all living with the consequences too and as participants in helping cause them we should indeed be held responsible for doing something about it.

[CdnFox]

2 hours ago, eyeball said:

I'm pretty sure vandalism is a crime.

You want to charge them with mischief?

2 hours ago, eyeball said:

The awful and long term damage and consequences of this should give pause to consider making things like the partition plan used to make way for colonization a crime against humanity.

No the awful long-term damage and consequences of this should make the Palestinians realize that they were complete dumb fcuks and Cause them to abandon their ignorant hostility towards Israel and try and find a way to work together to have peace and prosperity

I don't think they're smart enough for that and I don't think Israel thinks they're smart enough for that so they're looking at option b, make sure they never ever get to a position where they can threaten Israel again.

Palestine and Gaza had a choice. This is what they chose. Let them live with it

[Army Guy]

8 hours ago, ExFlyer said:

UN resolution 181.

Middle East 1920's 

You are incorrect. Only time I made comment was when I was addressed.

I never once said Iran should or could nuke Israel..  I said "

Your wiki is not about Israel.

I end with my opinion and stand by it but, some like you keep addressing me and I respond.

Again, I am not going. to argue with you...goodbye.

 

 

not sure why i'm bothering...you have posted to many topics about Israel in the past, be it if you where addressed or not...

That is your quote below right...unless there is another flyer...So you did post it...

On 7/27/2025 at 9:33 AM, ExFlyer said:

Why should Canadian protect Israel??? They have killed far more Arabs and get praised for it??

Should Canadians not protect the innocents being killed by indiscriminate bombing by Israel? 

Really do not care what goes on in the Middle East. It has been a constant problem since State of Israel was thrust upon the world.

Quote

Iran could nuke the entire region and it would not be missed.

 

100 % right it is about the which countries came into being from the french madidate and british mandate, it is funny that all those you mentioned were where created by the league of nations and the UN, and did not exist before that...

Of course your not going to argue becasue your wrong...the source i gave you proves that....

[eyeball]

1 hour ago, CdnFox said:

You want to charge them with mischief?

Not them, but us and our allies, for telling refugees go to Palestine and kick the people who live there out.

1 hour ago, CdnFox said:

Palestine and Gaza had a choice. This is what they chose. Let them live with it

We gave them no more choice than we gave Jewish European refugees.

That's why we owe it to Israelis and Palestinians for the grief that's caused, but mostly to Palestinians. 

[CdnFox]

2 minutes ago, eyeball said:

Not them, but us and our allies, for telling refugees go to Palestine and kick the people who live there out.

I thought the charge you wanted was vandalism. Are you suggesting we vandalized the refugees first?   LOL

4 minutes ago, eyeball said:

We gave them no more choice than we gave Jewish European refugees

We didn't have anything to do with it. They have a choice they made their choice and now they're living and dying with their choice. And they could still make a different choice right now, but they choose to die.  

It's entirely their decision. 

[ExFlyer]

1 hour ago, Army Guy said:

not sure why i'm bothering....

I do not know either. 

I already said Goodbye.

[I am Groot]

12 hours ago, Barquentine said:

 It wasn't the Israelis who did that. It was American money. Still is.

Nope. The US wasn't all that interested in Israel in the early going. It wasn't until the late 50s and the cold war that the US really sought out Israel in a region where the Soviets were making inroads with nationalist Arab governments.

12 hours ago, Barquentine said:

So one genocide justifies another?

There is no genocide in that area, unless it's over the border in Syria, where the Turks are trying to slaughter the Kurds and the Islamists are trying to kill all the Druze.

11 hours ago, Barquentine said:

By bombing hospitals, killing children and starving the entire population?

Hospitals are legitimate war targets if they have soldiers, weapons and headquarters positions in or under them.

You don't have any idea how many 'children' have been killed, or why. And I've seen no indication the population is starving.

[I am Groot]

On 7/27/2025 at 1:43 PM, eyeball said:

Israel has turned itself into a monstrosity - an affront to human civilization.

Oh whine whine. Go cry somewhere else, grandma.

[I am Groot]

On 7/27/2025 at 4:35 PM, ExFlyer said:

judaism (Israel) conscripts all youth "Military service is compulsory for all Jews and Druze, both men and women, and for Circassian men. The active-duty period is 32 months for men and 24 months for women, followed by reserve duty until age 40."

I think your hate for a religion is clouded.

Have a good day.

Are you NINE? Do you really imagine this was clever?

20 hours ago, Nationalist said:

This Canadian has no love for Isreal. Let them fight their own wars.

And if everyone says that about us, what then?

Edited July 28, 2025 by I am Groot