Black Dog

I don't think that;'s the case, I think they're mostly sad old boomers with too much time on their hands.

I've read Zitelmann's “Hitler’s National Socialism" and I think you're misrepresenting his arguments if you think he's arguing "Hitler was a socialist". It's much more complicated than that. Again, this might work if your own arguments weren't written in half chewed crayons. But alas. Hitler wasn't a socialist. He wasn't a free market libertarian either. He saw value in elements of both systems. At the end of the day, every single school of socialism includes the necessity that the means of production are held by the workers, either directly through cooperative or collective ownership or indirectly through representative democracies. Given the Nazis did not own the means of production and were not a representative democracy, they were not socialists.

LOL why would you get that from me saying I have nothing but contempt for you. lol ok sure man.

You're mistaking my contempt for anger. You're the guy wasting his life watching shit like the Sunday morning talkshows and the View and getting angry about them to the point that you come on here and tell lies.

Which is it dumbass? lol do you think anyone weird enough to be posting on "an obscure forum" is uncommitted? Furthermore, do you think your "writing" which is really just of simply regurgitating whatever slop is currently percolating in your right wing echo chamber is actually persuasive? Because to that i say: lol. I never said anything about you being lazy or unemployed, I simply pointed out you spend an awful lot of time watching and getting mad at the TV.

I think most credible historians are on my side here like Richard Evans and Adam Tooze. Who you got: Dinesh Dsouza lol? And? This is pretty funny coming from a bunch of sub-literate apes whose thought process on this can be summed up as "Hitler = Bad, Socialism = Bad, therefore Hitler = Socialist."

Makes sense given what the song YMCA is about.

Do you do anything but sit on your fat ass and watch TV all day? No wonder you like Trump, he's a kindred spirit.

A leaky FBI and a corrupt president doing crimes? Yeah that sounds about right.

LOl you didn't even read the article that was the basis of the blog you posted, did you, retardo? Because if you did, you'd know Germany had an extensive social welfare state before the Nazis came along. By your retarded logic, Otto Von Bismarck was therefore a socialist. LMAO.

They were as socialist as the People's Democratic Republic of Korea is a democracy.

You should read your own sources and apply an iota of critical thinking. It's clear that, to Hitler, using "socialism" in the name was a branding exercise and nothing else. It's obvious what he considers socialism has nothing in common with how the term is used or understood in any other context. Again: the Nazis didn't advocate for collective ownership of the means of production. They didn't believe in equality. They didn't see the world through the lens of class conflict.

Last time a President appointed a FBI Director with no qualifications other than being a sycophantic taint-licker, the whole place sprung more leaks than a colander and it ended with Watergate.

I'd love to, tell me what care home you live in and i'll come push your walker over.

You're an aging loser with some kind of chronic health problem, don't talk about other being broken here stupid. Oh is that where you're getting your infop? Makes sense it is total bullshit. You should try reading a book instead and then maybe you wouldn't say retarded shit like "there was no right wing in Weimar Germany." LOl there's nothing to argue with here, you don't bring anything to the table. I mean look at this pathetic series of "rebuttals". At the end of the day, the Nazis were not socialists. They had no real beliefs about class conflict. They loved private property and allowed private enterprises freedom to operate and pursue profits. They banned trade unions and socialist organisations and political parties. Their welfare state was structured only for the benefit of Aryan Volk and not society at large. Like i told you the last time you embarrassed yourself pretending to know anything about the Nazis: everything they did was driven by their social Darwinist and racial beliefs. Again: read a book, preferably something by an actual historian or political scientist.