Jump to content

Layton/NDP plan to vote against budget no matter what


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 88
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

This is why I don't vote NDP. They oppose for the sake of opposing (well, all parties do but the NDP is probably the worst at it). Ever heard of the boy who cried wolf?

My goodnes...an opposition party opposing the government. Why they probably sit 'opposite' the government seats in the house too!

What we need is an opposition parties that actually support the governing party - that would be true opposition.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My goodnes...an opposition party opposing the government. Why they probably sit 'opposite' the government seats in the house too!

What we need is an opposition parties that actually support the governing party - that would be true opposition.

So you don't think parties should work together??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

LOL, Canadians would rather have an election then let the Bloc lead the entire country. Harper never let the Bloc lead the country like Layton and Ignatieff are ready to do. Say they take the PMO in a CoupScam, when it falls apart and we go to an election and the Tories win a majority will you come back and apologize to me and say I was right?

The Bloc has often been in the unique position of holding a balance of power. Aside from Harper using them in his 2004 Coalition, he has made special deals with them at least 14 times to pass various motions. You might say that technically they already 'lead the entire country'. Neither Harper nor the NDP/Liberal Coalition, which will remain together in spirit, can do anything without them.

Fanning the fires of national disunity "Mr. Harper is launching hypocritical attacks that can lead to a national disaster, and, with the time prorogation has granted him, he will no doubt continue to promote disunity. Consider the following falsehoods that he, his ministers and their party are spreading:

1. The Bloc is part of the Liberal-NDP coalition. It's not. But it is providing needed stability by signing an agreement not to bring down the coalition during its first 18 months. Mr. Harper has relied on the Bloc 14 times in votes, and twice on budget ones."

In fact, it's probably better for the Bloc if Harper holds onto power for awhile, because ultimately they have all the power. However, if his government falls and the GG asks Ignatieff to take the reins, the Bloc cannot vote freely on confidence motions...the big guys...like budgets, etc. They are willing to set aside their agenda for a year and a half. Harper is not.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think most people just want our politicians to stop screwing around and start dealing with the country's business.

Precisely what PM Harper and the Tories are doing. The Separatist Bloc and the NDP will vote against it no matter what's in it as their lust for power in all encompassing. The Liberals are taking the classic position of sitting on the fence.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Precisely what PM Harper and the Tories are doing. The Separatist Bloc and the NDP will vote against it no matter what's in it as their lust for power in all encompassing. The Liberals are taking the classic position of sitting on the fence.

Pfffft, Harper and the supposi'Tories CAUSED this whole mess with their partisan attacks in the fiscal update. They can't be trusted and should be removed, the budget is irrelevant. Harper is a snake needs to be cast out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Even though I don't agree with Layton on some issues, I understand why he said it. Harper has PROMISED, in one of his budgets, money for municipalities, and Jack had talked to them and asked what have they done with the money that Harper had promised to give them. The mayors had said they are still waiting for that money. On the news recently farmer's are still waiting for their money the government promised, also. So this is why Layton said he has lost confidence in the government, and understandly, I agree, but he still should keep an open mind on this budget.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Layton has completely shot his wad with his unwavering support of the dead duck coalition.

He has no game left, hence his bizarre posturing and crowing about voting against a budget he has not seen.

Does he think this will increase or even retain support for his party?

As strange as it sounds it'll probably stay about the same as people on the left hate Harper or any Tory anyhow. They'll soon start bashing the Liberals and saying that we cannot tell the difference between Igantieff and Harper or some such nonsense. That seat they have in Alberta will be gone though, no doubt about that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Even though I don't agree with Layton on some issues, I understand why he said it. Harper has PROMISED, in one of his budgets, money for municipalities, and Jack had talked to them and asked what have they done with the money that Harper had promised to give them. The mayors had said they are still waiting for that money. On the news recently farmer's are still waiting for their money the government promised, also. So this is why Layton said he has lost confidence in the government, and understandly, I agree, but he still should keep an open mind on this budget.

I agree with the Tory stance of the municipalities putting up equal money to the amount they want. This shows that they don't just want a handout but are comitted to doing some work too. Topaz, you can't take everything Layton says at face value, he is a politician after all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Layton has completely shot his wad with his unwavering support of the dead duck coalition.

I can assure you that the Coalition is anything but dead and is free of cracks. In fact, the solidarity has been strengthened the past couple of weeks. As for Layton's wad. He's been given Viagra and is raring to go.

1. Show me the money

2. No broad based tax cuts.

Unwavering.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with the Tory stance of the municipalities putting up equal money to the amount they want. This shows that they don't just want a handout but are comitted to doing some work too. Topaz, you can't take everything Layton says at face value, he is a politician after all.

Layton isn't the only one saying about no delivery on the money, the Libs are saying it and so are the mayors and other leaders of the communities. I keep asking were did Harper spend the 12 BILLION+3???????????????????????????????????

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That matching crap is about as slow-motion and dishonest as it gets.

I didn't like it when done by previous administrations, and to do it now is nothing short of obstruction.

Worse, matching provides the most cash to those who need it least, and the least to those who need it most.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That matching crap is about as slow-motion and dishonest as it gets.

I didn't like it when done by previous administrations, and to do it now is nothing short of obstruction.

Worse, matching provides the most cash to those who need it least, and the least to those who need it most.

It does? How does asking municipalities to invest in their future in partnership with the Feds equal obstruction?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Municipalities don't have puddles of money waiting around in anticipation of one-time matching grants, nor do they have the unrestricted power to borrow-- both of those circumstances largely due to regulations that they have no hand in making.

If they don't have, and can't get that money, then they can't match, and there is no grant.

Right now, there is serious urgency about getting projects up and running. To force the wheels to slow to the pace at which municalities can access matching funds is to OBSTRUCT the stated objective of the grants.

(And you already knew that, but blow smoke for the similar sake of partisan obstruction.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Municipalities don't have puddles of money waiting around in anticipation of one-time matching grants, nor do they have the unrestricted power to borrow-- both of those circumstances largely due to regulations that they have no hand in making.

If they don't have, and can't get that money, then they can't match, and there is no grant.

Right now, there is serious urgency about getting projects up and running. To force the wheels to slow to the pace at which municalities can access matching funds is to OBSTRUCT the stated objective of the grants.

(And you already knew that, but blow smoke for the similar sake of partisan obstruction.)

Municipalities are great money wasters especially Mayor Miller and his band of idiots in Toronto.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Precisely what PM Harper and the Tories are doing.

If so, they better keep doing it.

Municipalities are great money wasters especially Mayor Miller and his band of idiots in Toronto.

Can't comment on Miller but I disagree with that statement in general. Municipal politicians have to be far more accountable than other levels of government as it is much more difficult for them to pass the buck and they have far fewer options when it comes to raising revenue. In BC at least, municipalities can only borrow to finance capital projects, unlike the feds or provinces who can borrow just to pay the light bill.

I can see the matching idea when it comes to sharing with the provinces, there is no reason the federal government should be the only one to go into deficit. It is everyones problem.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can assure you that the Coalition is anything but dead and is free of cracks. In fact, the solidarity has been strengthened the past couple of weeks.
NDP Leader Jack Layton appeared shocked Wednesday when the Liberals came out in support of the Conservatives' budget, effectively ending an unprecedented NDP-Grit coalition forged only two months ago to topple the Tory government.
"We have a new coalition now on Parliament Hill -- it's a coalition between Mr. Harper and Mr. Ignatieff,"

Bloc Quebecois Gilles Duceppe also addressed the media Wednesday to express his disdain for Ignatieff's decision.

"That's the end of the coalition," said Duceppe.
Ignatieff would not officially say the coalition was dead but his Quebec lieutenant, Denis Coderre, bluntly declared it "dead," according to The Canadian Press.
Ultimately, however, the Grits will make a power grab and will topple the Tories.

"That's their game plan. They've got wind in their sales now, they don't need to NDP and they certainly don't need the Bloc Quebecois," said Fife.

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/stor...28?hub=Politics

Stick a fork in it's ass, the coalition is done.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Municipalities don't have puddles of money waiting around in anticipation of one-time matching grants, nor do they have the unrestricted power to borrow-- both of those circumstances largely due to regulations that they have no hand in making.

MUnciipalities have the power of taxation and numerous other sources of revenue.

Nothing prevents them from raising funds for their projects, other than fear of their electorate and a willingness to pawn off responisbility to other levels of govt.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Tell a friend

    Love Repolitics.com - Political Discussion Forums? Tell a friend!
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      10,733
    • Most Online
      1,403

    Newest Member
    Videospirit
    Joined
  • Recent Achievements

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...