Army Guy

Sure if that is what it takes, as long as they are getting the metal health issues looked after , i think that would be problem solved.

Thats a solution...more divisiveness...why not solve it by sending the gay kids to gay school, where being gay can be celebrated 365 days a year, provide them with mental health counseling, and treatment.

The consequences of going to war with israel...why is that so hard to understand... So your unhappy with some of the UN choices..... join the club the end of the line is about 1000 miles that way...

I'm curious as to why Sing read the same report and got a totally different message...one says nothing to see here, the other is deeply concerned...and then there is the fact of why CSIS or the NSICOP reports suggest that something bad is going on...

Yes the report is top secret, so are the other numerous reports on this topic CSIS has crafted in the last several years...it might be mentioned that MAY had access to only one report not all of them...Your assuming that she has full knowledge of the topic , i suggested she does not , she read one report.... I did not call her a lair, i said she does not have full knowledge on the topic, or either misread the report opr did not understand it, or was lying about it take your pick anything is possible in todays politics...reading one report does not make you an subject matter expert... Once again why would CSIS craft a report on one ex MP , a report that has started a shit storm in the media...we will know soon enough someone is going to leak it to the press and the public will know...

You mean those palestinians that decided to take part in pushing the jews into the sea with their Arab counterparts and had their lands sized in conflict those palestinians...got it...well you know what happens when you f*ck with the bull, you get both horns, it's time to stop whining about it and start living with it... The point still remains the same, most Arab countries decided to kick out their jewish populations...not for a tit for tat, becasue they just did not want them in their lands... Just for the record, becasue it seems your making it up as you go, League of nations and the UN decided to give both palestinian and Jews their own states...it was not just Arabs that had to move but jews that owned lands in palestinian territory as well ...( I Know we don't talk about that part) but it is part of written record... Those arabs had a choice to make move or live in peace with the jews...

Last time i checked there was also Arabs enlisted to fight in both wars on both sides...you seen the movie Lawrence of arabia...all arabs ... That would be a great leftist decision...lets give them a chunk of germany, the same people that exterminated 6 million jews...Becasue that makes sense.....thats where the wanted to live right next to some of the concentration camps you know just for the reminder that everyone still hates them....lets forget jews that have lived in the Palestine area for thousands of years...lets forget the this is where Jews have the most history...

Somehow you seem to know what is "NOT" in the report...Why would CSIS produce a "top secret "report on MP's that may have been involved in foreign interference if it had no merit...Are they known for producing reports that make accusations that are not valid ?...are they working for the conservatives?...Are you telling readers that May has seen ALL the info on the subject or just what is in the report.....you tell us YOU are the one saying the report is false news...what do you know that we do not... What we DO know is that CSIS produced a report that casts one or more Canadian MP in a very bad light...your seem to be telling everyone move on nothing worth your time here...when the subject is worth everyone's time if true, and if it proves to be false then CSIS report authors need to be looked fired ....

I'm saying that CSIS is the author of the report, and reported facts that one or more MP's did help foreign agents... I'm saying May, said she did not see a list of mp's names that were listed, perhaps she misread the report or did not interrupted the report correctly..or she out right lied...or there were not a list of names.....Based upon what she said it implies there is nothing to see here....She said she is confident that NO mp's were guilty of treasonous acts... BUT and there is always a but CSIS thinks other wise or it would have stated so in the report....You've read top secret documents before they are not always black and white, they are based on the reader and the need to know...MAY , may have the clearance but really does not need to know all the facts...like the list of names... What i think is that CSIS did report on a subject it was suppose to, and reported what it did find...that some of our MP's did in fact help out foreign governments to what extent no one knows yet...

Your not much of a salesmen are you August...If these are the best talking points you could come up with....i could list a couple hundreds nations with the same talking points and truth be told they are not that interesting nor do they do much that matters...

Yes common ideas are bad to a modern society, it sounded like criticism to me, something you are having issues with. I mean come on Michael if we were a mature society we would not be on these forums, ...I think it is good to reflect on criticism , if only to see where we can evolve...In Canada we need to reflect on almost everything,

I guess all that dancing in the streets we seen all over the media, that was all fake, that was palestinians celebrating those 1200 israelis deaths....People that do not support the Oct 7 attacks don't dance in the streets... Now that Hamas is been beaten to a pulp...is there any sign today of palestinian standing up to take back control..."no" they are content with their current political situation....even when Hamas is almost extinct....Don't pretend you know what they want, they have been telling you and all the people like you what they want for decades now....The total destruction of Israel. That's is what you support...the destruction of an entire state...

How could it be misinformation, is it true or not did those cities have worse air quality or not...And not sure about your province but here in NB we have 4 people die in the waiting room in the last 2 years...No red flags there...our entire health care system is on life support and you still think it compares to any others that pay for health care... Or maybe his words hit to close to home, nobody likes criticism especially the left,or canadians and to suggest wokism does not exist in this country suggest your not aware of what is going on nationally or even in your own province...Why would anyone defend this government when it has actually broken everything it touched...with exception of pot, is was broken but is only half broken now... Growing our population has been a huge failure...in every sense...This is nothing to brag about it just further illustrates just how incompetent this government really is...The fact that your still standing behind them with your support is telling...

Well looking around the globe, we continue to see governments change form the left to right or in some case extreme right..just look at whats going to happen here in Canada, change is coming and most that are on the left are not going to like it...shit even some that say they are on the right are not going to like it...but then again change is never liked...

And yet here we are you supporting terrorist state, but screw the rest of the globe , i get it , it's so exhausting to support on conflict let alone all of them. Well if i had a choice,i like my choices rather than the one you made, i would never in a million years support the palestinian people or their terrorist ways... Cowardly...not exactly the word i would use but if it makes you sleep better then sure call me what ever you want, what i do know is when i was in the fighting terrorist i looked left and right and no one fitting your description was to be seen...Your forgetting Hamas was voted in by the people of palestine, with the majority of palestinians content with how things are being run....They may be funded by Iran and other middle eastern countries but it is Hamas that decides what it does or does not do....they and they alone are responsible for their actions... As for Iran I'm sure there will be a day when they are forced to eat a bag of D*cks , hopefully for a NATO coalition... Your ignoring that in my culture a man is not a man until they are 18 years of age...Hamas will recruit as young as 11, with being 15 is military age...By the time they reach the battle field they are full of hate, and would gladly kill you then drag your dead body through the streets, phone mom bragging how many jews they have killed....And i don't think of them as savages...just terrorists... I have never said you supported rape, torture and murder...but you do support those that do...I don't hate you eyeball, i may dislike what you support but i don't hate you....i do however hate terrorist

It is CSIS themselves that are the author of the report that there was MP's that helped a feign government help taint our elections. So who are we going to trust CSIS the guys that made the report or windbag May...now perhaps she is right, then CSIS needs to be investigated on the validity of the report, perhaps someone over there needs to be fired or let go... or May needs to justify her statement,or have some form of consequences. in any case it is far from over...

An American view on what Canada has become lately, none of it is good, no longer are we considered the polite and friendly nation, but rather the than the leading nation of woke...I like the end statement best it warns all those on the left "winter is coming" and your not going to like it....

This is just another example of just how little power the UN has...in the article it says Hamas is on board with the agreement, why would they not be, i mean for them it means life...continuation of this war means death...Israel however is not impressed no where in this agreement is it beneficial to them, i mean the UN has no power to enforce anything, with exceptions of sanctions, which do very little, i mean most of the world refuses to do business with Israel already...Not to mention a permanent cease fire...so what happens when Hamas starts to launch rockets again or the next terrorist attack....what happens then is israel allowed back in the gaza to destroy what ever construction has been built... Handing power back over to the Palestinian authority is just another terrorist group...why would they agree to this...Why would the palestinian people agree with this, why because they can't help themselves, they need to be controlled by terrorist... those of you that think there is a difference in terrorist and the palestinian people they are going to show you...in the next election if there is one...who they prefer, and what direction they prefer and it is not peace with Israel...Just a paused in hostilities until the terrorist regroup and recruit more terrorists to continue their ways.... UN Security Council adopts a cease-fire resolution aimed at ending Israel-Hamas war in Gaza (msn.com)

how many is a drove anyways...is it hundreds or thousands, or more....and i've asked this before over and over again, in Sudan and many other conflicts ongoing around the globe today.....they are killing much more civilians than in Gaza, but "you people" have not even mentioned those killings, why ? is it becasue they are not terrorist, not the same color , religion, why this terrorist group....... That's part of the problem here you're missing out on all the facts, first problem is hamas includes all of it's terrorist in those numbers, second if those fighters that are listed under 18 they are reported as children...Not to mention the exaggeration of those killed which has already been debunked by NGO's and the other aid groups... Why don't you do some research on urban warfare and do some comparison with other conflicts, and ask yourselves why is this conflict so important to YOU and people like you...why has a terrorist organization have you cheerleading for them....

Fill us in what else could they have done to minimizing collateral damage ? ...I'm curious as this point keeps coming up, is there any proof that this actually happens...that they intentional go out of their way to hit civilian targets....

I have to agree with most of what your have said. with a couple of exceptions, it personal does not bother me who or what you want to be called personally i always ask the waiter or waitress their name and stick to that.. I have had my own business and have made it a point to hire the best person with the most qualifications first, i did not have a chart on the wall with quotas for race or gender... Gyms, here on the base they have gone to a family type change room, want to change into other cloths or bathing suit you change in a change room with a door, and bench...there are no getting naked in the open any more...in the shower you must keep your bathing suit on at all times, until it is time to change then back into the changing room or change closet what ever you want to call it... I'm ok with all their antics as long as i'm not forced into their fantasy world...like being call a cat, dog, or the infinite amount of genders they think of... I'm polite about it all of it , until they are not... Gays have been in the military for decades, nobody really cared even in the Infantry, as long as they kept that to themselves.... today it is a little different where they can where whatever uniform or form of uniform they want...frankly it does not look professional and yes it matters... What is out of bounds is children and education, which is being forced on all children at all grade levels...that is a line that has been forced on all parents regardless of religion, race, or creed...

Again that is your opinion, you've yet to prove that Israel during it's planning phases for each attack does not include the safety of civilians...every military does to be in line with the signed Geneva conventions... Sorry that the smallest they come in, for a guided munition... so there was consideration for collateral damage... i would say a tragic mistake was made, incompetence on that one individual, you can't paint the entire army for one persons mistake...they are all not as perfect as you are... Then you misunderstanding the ROE, depending on the hams targets value, ie commander or other high value target then collateral damage to civilians can be overlooked...but for a normal grunt in the field, unless he is holding up an entire unit with machine gun fire then normally civilian lives take precedence.. Actually those aren't my words but another posters, i was using your reply as an example....depending on the circumstances on the ground that remark might be true. AAHH that how hamas estimates civilian deaths just pulls them from their orifices... That's not how this works, deaths and injuries are reported by morgue or hospital units...and confirmed by red cross or other Agency...Both sides use different weapons systems which leave different entrance and exit wounds....easy to say who killed who...

This is not about arabs or israelis...this is about war and conflict...killing women and children are a large part of that...not just in this conflict but every conflict globally...look at yourself for a second, where is your concern for other conflicts, just last week it was reported that in Sudan they were stacking civilians on the ground on top of each other to shoot them, to save on bullets...hundreds were killed intentionally...not a peep out of global leaders, citizen's, much less the majority of the media... But mention a school was bombed by Israel and the world loses' its mind...don't get me wrong it is tragic, and i pray i could change it somehow, but until they make magic bullets and bombs civilians are going to take the brunt of war...or until man finds other ways to solve it's issues without violence...That's not going to happen anytime soon...This conflict is no different than any others.... Maybe if people globally were forced to spend time in a war zone, see it first hand, smell what death smells like, taste what death tastes like, feel it both physically and mentally, until you go numb , until your no longer a functioning human....just another animal...killing for survival... if we did that we might be able to come up with different solutions...until then death and destruction is all that comes out of war...very little else of any good seems to materialize... This what a man looks like after being in combat way to long...look into his eyes...That is a Canadian soldier from the RCR regt, in Korea...Thats what numb looks like... https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2F4fg4vistna351.jpg

There are literally thousands upon thousands of moving pieces on the battlefield...mistakes happen in "every" conflict, so much so they invented a word for it collateral damage...why is that so hard to comprehend...you've yet to prove any of these accidents were intentional, intent on killing civilians, and civilians only...what you have is opinion....thats all. The conflict is mostly happening in Gaza which from 2005 was not occupied, it has been under the control and care of Hamas...it is now occupied and might be for a long time coming... GBU-39 are small diameter bombs, 250 lb bombs packed with almost 40 lbs of explosive, with a blast radius of over 300 meters ..fragmentation radius of just over 200 meters 4 lbs of high explosive would be enough to level your home to the basement... I read about it, once again thousands upon thousands of moving pieces on the battle field, someone screwed up and people are dead, mistakes are common on the battlefield.... It's not funney at all, your making assumptions without any proof at all...and the next poster will regurgitate what you have posted thinking it is true...when it is false news...Only you can monitor what you post, if there is no proof or valid source you should refrain from posting it... Once again give us some proof of how they are indifferent or willing to accept higher civilian causalities...open days of D-day, 15- 20,000 french civilians are killed on the areas around the landing sites...in just a few days......and today we are celebrating that very battle......those numbers would double prior to breaking out of the area deeper into france....How many civilians died in the bombing of dresden, germany.... 46,000 civilians were killed in Afghanistan conflict by coalition members... the list goes on and on... I did not say they were military targets, todays rules of war are written to limit the amount of civilian casualties, but even with these rules civilians still die at a higher rate than any other group...hence the word collateral damage....I didn't invent the word or nor did i say killing civilians is OK, but it happens in every conflict, to often...and when your fighting in a urban area, those numbers triple or more... Once again prove it, or it is all opinion, and like a$$ holes everyone has one... It is not false, UN and UNRWA has told the media it had members take part in the attack, including hiding or keeping hostages....why would they go public if it was not true.... You said Significant numbers of israelis killed during the raid was killed by IDF...12 or 14 does not make a significant number, in fact it is a small percentage....these decisions are made in mere minutes or seconds, there is no sleeping on it to ensure you make the right decision..are they always right no they are not...Have you always made split second decisions that have alway turned out right...no you have not...but somehow you expect soldiers to be perfect, they are not robots they are human and prone to making mistakes that cost lives...war and conflict are governed by murphy's law, if it can go wrong it will...now if your a perfect person, and make no mistakes then every nation would love to have you in their military...but you have chosen a different path, one that includes an armchair so you can judge others...

BBC reports less than 50 %...have been destroyed...looks like he was right, again your making your facts up aren't you... https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-68006607