"Not Criminally Responsible" should be abolished from the legal system.

[blackbird]

NCR is something relatively new in Canada. "In 1992, Bill C-30 came into force which reformed (at least partially) the law as it relates to the defence of “not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder”. 

NCR rulings are making a mockery of the justice system and actually punishing the families of the victims because murderers are getting off and walking away, while the families have to suffer lifelong consequences including attending hearings about whether to release the offender from a mental facility.  This is unreasonable and punishes the families more than the offender who should face punishment for his heinous act.

quote

Moral Responsibility

Moral responsibility in the biblical context refers to the obligation of individuals to act according to God's commandments and ethical principles. It is rooted in the belief that humans, created in the image of God (Genesis 1:27), possess the capacity to discern right from wrong and are accountable for their actions. The Bible emphasizes that moral responsibility is not only about personal conduct but also involves the welfare of others and the community.

The concept of moral responsibility is evident throughout Scripture. In Deuteronomy 30:19, Moses presents the Israelites with a choice between life and death, blessing and curse, urging them to "choose life, so that you and your descendants may live." This passage underscores the importance of making choices aligned with God's will. Similarly, in Micah 6:8, the prophet declares, "He has shown you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you but to act justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God?"

The New Testament further elaborates on moral responsibility through the teachings of Jesus and the apostles. Jesus' Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5-7) provides a comprehensive guide to righteous living, emphasizing internal purity and the spirit of the law over mere external compliance. In Matthew 5:16, Jesus instructs His followers, "Let your light shine before men, that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in heaven."

The apostle Paul also addresses moral responsibility, particularly in his letters to the early churches. In Romans 14:12, he writes, "So then, each of us will give an account of himself to God." This statement highlights the personal accountability each believer has before God. Paul further encourages believers to bear one another's burdens (Galatians 6:2) and to live in a manner worthy of their calling (Ephesians 4:1).
unquote

Topical Bible: Moral Responsibility and Silence

I understand not everyone believes the Bible;  however, we are talking about basic commands that are enshrined in law such as "thou shalt not kill".  Everyone knows these laws and should be held accountable equally without some loophole that they were not in their right mind when they committed the crime.  Such excuses are purely subjective and are used to escape justice.  Psychiatry has invented these loopholes and the general public and political leaders have swallowed it completely.  It has destroyed out system of justice.

One appalling example is the man who murdered his kids in Merritt years ago.  He was held in some kind of mental facility since that time, but recently was released into community, possibly the Vancouver or lower mainland area, with a new name.  Another case was the man who beheaded a passenger on a Greyhound bus.  He was released after a few years.

Edited 14 hours ago by blackbird

[eyeball]

1 hour ago, blackbird said:

I understand not everyone believes the Bible;  however, we are talking about basic commands that are enshrined in law such as "thou shalt not kill".

When you are detached from reality by means of schizophrenia you are not thou.

The Bible doesn't mention mental illness. The terms profound emotional distress, severe psychological turmoil, and cognitive breakdown are nowhere to be found.

You'll see terms like madness, astonishment of heart, or physical descriptions but the Bible also makes it clear the victims of these conditions are not responsible.

The Lord will afflict you with madness, blindness and confusion of mind. (Deuteronomy 28:28)

There is actual physical damage to brain tissue in the case of schizophrenia. WTF does God think he's doing?  He must be out of his mind.

Edited 13 hours ago by eyeball

[blackbird]

11 hours ago, eyeball said:

When you are detached from reality by means of schizophrenia you are not thou.

The Bible doesn't mention mental illness. The terms profound emotional distress, severe psychological turmoil, and cognitive breakdown are nowhere to be found.

You'll see terms like madness, astonishment of heart, or physical descriptions but the Bible also makes it clear the victims of these conditions are not responsible.

The Lord will afflict you with madness, blindness and confusion of mind. (Deuteronomy 28:28)

There is actual physical damage to brain tissue in the case of schizophrenia. WTF does God think he's doing?  He must be out of his mind.

Personally I don't buy into the NCR defense for various reasons.  For one thing it is often impossible to tell.  It often rests on some very clever and expensive lawyer who knows how to spin it and they bring in some psychiatrist.  Psychiatry in this area is a very subjective and theoretical area.  It is often just a matter of opinion.  Also psychiatrists to some degree may be a kind of cult and they are committed to theoretical beliefs.  That's how they make their living, so what do you expect? There is no scientific basis for much of psychiatry.  It is built on theories invented by people like Sigmund Freud. 

quote 

Freud's Psychiatric Theories

Sigmund Freud's psychiatric theories are foundational to modern psychology, particularly in the field of psychoanalysis. His theories include:

The Id, Ego, and Superego: Freud's model of the psyche, where the Id represents primitive drives, the Ego is the conscious and rational part, and the Superego is the moral conscience. 

Psychosexual Stages: Freud proposed that children go through several stages of psychosexual development, each with its own set of conflicts and resolutions. Fixation at any stage can lead to adult personality traits. 

The Unconscious Mind: Freud believed that the unconscious contains powerful thoughts and feelings that influence behavior and decision-making. 

unquote

There are a lot of conflicting beliefs about Freud's theories.  Many rejected his theories as not credible.  They reject his claims of an Id, Ego, and Superego.

All of it is just pure theory and quite possibly false.   

The point is if the justice system goes by this kind of thing, fundamental justice is denied.  It is the victim's family who suffers for it.  There is no justice and society is put in danger.  Criminals know they might be able to get away with murder.  Nobody is safe.  The murderer gets off.

 

Edited 2 hours ago by blackbird

[eyeball]

1 minute ago, blackbird said:

Personally I don't buy into the NCR defense for various reasons.  For one thing it is often impossible to tell.  It often rests on some very clever and expensive lawyer who knows how to spin it and they bring in some psychiatrist.

Do they ever bring in a priest to spin Deuteronomy 28:28?

That should really clinch it don't you think?

[John Johnston]

2 hours ago, blackbird said:

Personally I don't buy into the NCR defense for various reasons.  For one thing it is often impossible to tell.  It often rests on some very clever and expensive lawyer who knows how to spin it and they bring in some psychiatrist.  Psychiatry in this area is a very subjective and theoretical area.  It is often just a matter of opinion.  Also psychiatrists to some degree may be a kind of cult and they are committed to theoretical beliefs.  That's how they make their living, so what do you expect? There is no scientific basis for much of psychiatry.  It is built on theories invented by people like Sigmund Freud. 

quote 

Freud's Psychiatric Theories

Sigmund Freud's psychiatric theories are foundational to modern psychology, particularly in the field of psychoanalysis. His theories include:

The Id, Ego, and Superego: Freud's model of the psyche, where the Id represents primitive drives, the Ego is the conscious and rational part, and the Superego is the moral conscience. 

Psychosexual Stages: Freud proposed that children go through several stages of psychosexual development, each with its own set of conflicts and resolutions. Fixation at any stage can lead to adult personality traits. 

The Unconscious Mind: Freud believed that the unconscious contains powerful thoughts and feelings that influence behavior and decision-making. 

unquote

All of this is just pure theory and quite possibly false.   

The point is if the justice system goes by this kind of thing, fundamental justice is denied.  It is the victim's family who suffers for it.  There is no justice and society is put in danger.  Criminals know they might be able to get away with murder.  Nobody is safe.  The murderer gets off.

 

Ok there Doctor Internet. 

[herbie]

"Not Criminally Responsible" should be abolished from the legal system

No it shouldn't it's a basic principle of law.

That's why you're not a Judge and never will be.

[blackbird]

23 minutes ago, herbie said:

"Not Criminally Responsible" should be abolished from the legal system

No it shouldn't it's a basic principle of law.

That's why you're not a Judge and never will be.

That's why we have murderers released into society with new names.  Thanks to people like you.

[blackbird]

1 hour ago, John Johnston said:

Ok there Doctor Internet. 

We have mental institutions for people who lose their minds and commit serious crimes.  The problem is serious murderers who got off on NCR are then later often released back into society by people who don't care about the protection of society or justice, people like yourself.

 No murderer whether some psychiatrist claims he didn't know what he was doing should ever be released back into society.   Who can guarantee he will never commit the same crime again?  If he was mentally detached from reality when he murdered his family one time, who says he will not commit murder again and then claim he was not criminally responsible?   The system is completely flawed.

Edited 9 hours ago by blackbird

[herbie]

5 hours ago, blackbird said:

That's why we have murderers released into society with new names.  Thanks to people like you.

WTF do either NCR or 'people like me' have to do with people changing their names?

[blackbird]

25 minutes ago, herbie said:

WTF do either NCR or 'people like me' have to do with people changing their names?

It's people like you that are the reason we have an NCR law and dangerous murderers being released back into society.  Same thing with the catch and release system that has been releasing offenders with long records of sometimes more than fifty arrests and offences.  It is well known you support soft-on-crime laws that we have from the Liberals (with the support of the NDP).

[herbie]

oh, you mean nrmaql people like me that understand mentally challenged people can't be judged the same as competent ones? 
Unlike those who no pumichemtn is severe and Biblical enough in these lax modern times.

Yeo, caught with a joint three times - life without psrole in solitary with only bread and water.

[Gaétan]

2 hours ago, blackbird said:

It's people like you that are the reason we have an NCR law and dangerous murderers being released back into society.  Same thing with the catch and release system that has been releasing offenders with long records of sometimes more than fifty arrests and offences.  It is well known you support soft-on-crime laws that we have from the Liberals (with the support of the NDP).

The rule you apply to others also applies to you. So if you condemn others, you will be condemned as well. Do you believe you are without sin?