
On Guard for Thee
Member-
Posts
13,543 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by On Guard for Thee
-
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
You seem to want to keep blaming it on the police somehow. Pursuing charges is at the discretion of the crown. Apparently they thought there was sufficient evidence. Add to that the crown has ample opportunity to interview the complainants prior to trial, and you may get why you might conclude shoddy from them. -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
It's the crown that decides whether or not to proceed with charges, not the police. Once again, the crown decided there was sufficient evidence, but presenting it seems to have fallen short. -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
Apparently they disclosed enough to police that when it got to the crown, charges were deemed appropriate. Which once again goes to the concept of lax pre trial preperation. -
Islamophobia in Canada
On Guard for Thee replied to Hudson Jones's topic in Federal Politics in Canada
That's quite a story. But other than xenophobia, can you provide any reason for these wild assumptions? -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
So you don't think choking someone is assault? -
Islamophobia in Canada
On Guard for Thee replied to Hudson Jones's topic in Federal Politics in Canada
Apparently the people who took delivery of the 118 million acres wanted to live there. I bet many of their ancestors still do. -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
No one is suggesting repressing that information, simply learning to disregard it as irrelevant. As stated, what is important is what happened at the time of the alleged assault. If Ghomeshi was choking someone and was asked to stop and didn't, that's assault. What happened the next day/week/month doesn't matter. -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
I think it could well be totally irrelevant. If Ghomeshi committed a crime of assault, and the victims made some later attempt to contact, possibly with the idea of rectification, it doesn't change what was previously done a whit. -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
This actually has nothing to do with removing the blindfold from justice, but rather keeping it in place. Assault victims have had cases go against them based on spurious questions about how short a skirt they were wearing and such nonsense. This outdated concept seems to think if you dress sexy, you must want sex and so "dang it, I was just givin' her what she wanted". I don't think clear minded people believe that is justified in any way. -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
Oh of course, this case is all over but the cryin'. But yes, I think a worthy effort from legal experts going forward would be to figure a way to better level the playing field. As I say, rape shield was an attempt, long ago, that seems to need some serious modifications. -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
You can tinker with format but still must respect the rights of all parties. The rape shield law was an attempt to stop harassment of assault complainants, but it seems to not be applied all that evenly, especially in jury cases were the old style can be used but by the time an objection is ruled on, the jury may already be to some extent tainted. Civil cases are a different format that already exists, although it won't provide for punishment beyond financial, but it's something. -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
It is highly unlikely we will change the "beyond a reasonable" doubt portion of criminal decisions, so these types of cases will likely continue to be a bit one sided against complainants. What assaulted women may begin to do is seek restitution through civil cases. We all know OJ was guilty, and walked. That didn't stop the affected families from taking him back to court and winning. -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
I'll get some popcorn and wait to see your description of "the corner". -
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
It could well be the case that these complainants were bound to fail inevitably, however the reporting I heard of how they fell apart under very basic questioning under cross is what tells me that they weren't prepped very well. In other words, the discrepancies should have been discovered prior to trial. Not suggesting their testimony should have been somehow rigged, that's totally not allowed, but they could/should have been made aware what types of questions would be asked, and how to deal with things such as failure of memory, especially after such a long time lapse. -
Canada Shunned by Coalition Allies
On Guard for Thee replied to cannuck's topic in Federal Politics in Canada
I guess you forgot about "Odyssey Dawn"- 358 replies
-
Canada Shunned by Coalition Allies
On Guard for Thee replied to cannuck's topic in Federal Politics in Canada
The jets are headed home soon, Trudeau did what he said he would. The allies seem quite happy with the alternate plan. Let's wait to see how it works.- 358 replies
-
I believe we have all heard how good Harper was at allocating funds here or there, but then never actually getting it out the door. I doubt JT would have been so open about pledging money to Alta. if he was planning the same kind of trickery.
- 192 replies
-
- Federalism
- Western Alienation
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
How about an extra 700 mil. for infrastructure, over and above what will come out in the budget.
- 192 replies
-
- Federalism
- Western Alienation
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Jian Ghomeshi Fired from Q
On Guard for Thee replied to Michael Hardner's topic in Media and Broadcasting
One of those procedural issues was the lack of preparation of the complainants by the crown. But that has already been pointed out to you, but you don't seem to understand it. No sense wasting more time on it. -
Conservative Surplus Nothing but Hot Air
On Guard for Thee replied to Smallc's topic in Federal Politics in Canada
Apparently Harper wasn't aware of that concept. -
Changes coming to immigration language rules.
On Guard for Thee replied to PIK's topic in Federal Politics in Canada
I was just pointing out how actual stats fly in the face of your previous post about how immigrants have done in Canada. I think you don't need me to explain how a language barrier could be a setback, but obviously previous immigrants got over that. You learned a language once, and so can they.