....which clearly states: "No reproduction without permission" at the bottom. I reviewed this with Greg and the image is back up on display.
No. It is not a definable concept. Rather, it is a subjective judgement.
Take advantage of the constructive criticism your readers have provided. Demonstrate your intentions by re-starting your discussion. You can do it.
Nobody is being punished. The only posts taken down from your thread were trolling.
... decide for themselves how they can improve the 2nd draft.
That depends on the nature of the post to which a member responds.
If a member responds to that which he believes to be trolling, then the member is guilty of feeding trolling. Feeding trolling is a shameful act.
Sometimes perception matters.
Little by little, folks are starting to get it.
We recognize that modus operandi.
There is more to this particular story: The mod staff simply did not agree on intervention. Try to work that into the flow charts.
The mod staff arrived at a compromise that would minimize censorship and allow the discussion to continue. We leave folks with the freedom to demonstrate their intentions by starting a 2nd thread.