We all know this is a government of style over substance. We've seen Trudeau's narcissism and desperate need to be liked all the way from when he was in college and doing stupid things to get people to look at him, including his wild array of costumes he never grew out of. We can see his policies designed for visual appeal rather than substance.
Bill Morneau, however, gives us a glimpse of life on the inside. And how dismayed he found to discover that even as Finance Minister, he just wasn't important enough for Trudeau to pay any attention to. Morneau rarely got to speak to Trudeau except when the latter was surrounded by advisors. And Trudeau just wasn't interested in policy. A few descriptions from his book say as much. The PMO cared about the news cycle and politics, not about actual governing.
By his own telling, his personal interaction with Mr. Trudeau was virtually non-existent. The two men rarely met. When they did, the PM was usually surrounded by advisers, precluding the opportunity for frank, one-on-one exchanges.
The portrait of his time in government that Mr. Morneau paints in his new book, Where To From Here, serves as a cautionary tale for future leaders on how not to alienate the best members of their teams and a disillusioning insider account about how the Trudeau government works. A Bay Street veteran with solid business credentials, Mr. Morneau’s talents were largely wasted in a government that obsesses about winning the news cycle and cares little about fiscal matters.
“My job providing counsel and direction where fiscal matters were concerned had deteriorated into serving as something between a figurehead and a rubber stamp,” he writes. “There was only revision of my recommendations, ever upward, toward funding levels the PMO believed would play well the next time Canada went to the polls.”
When it comes to the massive splurge of spending around the pandemic, Morneau is clear that it wasn't what he had wanted.
"We lost the agenda. During the period when the largest government expenditures as a portion of GDP were made in the shortest time since the advent of World War II, calculations and recommendations from the Ministry of Finance were basically disregarded in favour of winning a popularity contest," he writes. "In a moment where I saw us taking decisions that were more significant than I thought we needed, it was frankly, extremely frustrating," Morneau said in the interview. "I think in that moment, you know, it started to sow the seeds of a challenge. That we just weren't going to be able to recover."
So the next time Liberals try to tell you all that spending was necessary, remember what they mean is 'necessary to help our election chances'.
Further on his inability to discuss things with Trudeau one on one he says that isn't just about him. Trudeau never discussed anything with his cabinet one on one. Morneau mentions this when he talks of his resignation.
He writes it was one of the "very few" times the two had discussed something in private without any other advisers or sources of counsel in the room which "simply didn't happen" in Trudeau's world.
"Virtually any topic you wanted to discuss with the prime minister—official or informal, strategy or gossip—had to be shared in the presence of members of his staff," he writes.
That says to me Trudeau doesn't believe he has the capability to deal with issues on his own, that he needs staff around him to provide the council on all the subjects he lacks knowledge of and to reign in his impulse to respond through is own judgement. This says nothing good about Trudeau as a leader. And that is one of the other things Morneau mentions, Trudeau's inability to develop interpersonal relationships with his cabinet ministers. He might be the smiley, charming guy for the press but in government he apparently keeps his distance. Which is odd. Harper was famously an introvert but he did establish a number of close relationships with cabinet ministers. Maybe Harper didn't have to fear every conversation would be in waters over his head the way Trudeau does.
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/article-bill-morneaus-talents-were-wasted-in-justin-trudeaus-ottawa/
https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/morneau-says-pm-favoured-political-points-over-policy-felt-like-rubber-stamp-ahead-of-inevitable-resignation-1.6221671