marcus Posted November 16, 2015 Author Report Posted November 16, 2015 Jews are indigenous to Israel as aboriginal people are to Canada This is not true. Once again you're trying to re-write history. Majority of Jews in Israel have very little connection to the region and the ancient Canaanites and ancient Hebrews, whereas majority of the Arabs, have not only lived there for centuries, but they also have a closer blood connection to the Canaanites and ancient Hebrews. Quote "What do you think of Western civilization?" Gandhi was asked. "I think it would be a good idea," he said.
cannuck Posted November 17, 2015 Report Posted November 17, 2015 Canuck your post made no sense. The Arab League in fact was rejected by the Arab League of nations so your entire premises that the Jews did not follow the Balfour Declaration and trigged the current conflicts is illogical. It was in fact the Arab League that rejected the doctrine not Israel. Your words have used the conflict as a pretext to blame all Jews. Your use of the word Jews in your response made that clear. You exemplify and illustrate how you couch your discussion on a conflict supposedly caused by Zionists, but then use the reference Jews to blame all Jews. Your repeat again for the second thread of yours that Zionists invented terrorism.. Please, provide the proof Zionists invented terrorism and while you are at it that they rejected the Balfour Decleration. The rest of your post also made zero sense. Jews are indigenous to Israel as aboriginal people are to Canada and yet you use some fractured reference that appears to discuss aboriginal land rights as if indigenous people are entitled to them unless of course they are "Jews".. Thanks for your valuable arm chair opinion but let me remind you once again we JEWS have the same rights as anyone to national an universal sufferage. We didn't invent terrorism, but some of us will sure as hell deal with it. One last thing, you want to lump all Jews in your tirades, understand something-you'll know where to find me and it won't be in the place you want to put all Jews. Oh believe me on that. If it is any great comfort, your reply made no sense either. The subject of the sentence regarding the Balfour Declaration was Palestinians, not Jews. Sorry if you missed that. As to Zionists inventing terrorism: I am not a history student, but I consider the Zealots the predecessors of what is now Zionism. Zealots would wander into crowds of innocent bystanders, pull out large knives and start hacking people to death. The invention of terrorism as we know it today. In only some ways are Jews aboriginals of Israel vs. what currently are considered aboriginal Canadians. Possibly during Roman occupation, and DEFINITELY during Arab occupation, the lands that are now Israel were NOT occupied by organized Jewish governments, only religious Jewish factions. The period in question is closer to 2 millenia, whereas Canadian aboriginals were displaced from most of their ancestral lands only within the last century or three. They have a somewhat legitimate claim on those lands by treaty. Jews had no such claim on Israel until, GEEZ, the same damned SLIMEY LIMEYS declared that Israel should just be carved out of Palestine. If you want to go on another rant, I suggest you and the Palestinians address it to Her Majesty. Nowhere did I suggest the League of Nations nor Jews had rejected the Balfour declaration. The question I DID ask is how long after being absent to any land is such a right precedent to those of the people who have occupied it for centuries in their absence? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.