Clubbob

Khadr was brought to Afghanistan by his parents he didn't choose to go there.

Inadmissible evidence since it was acquired through torture making those convictions moot so no he wasn't properly convicted. He was 15 when captured making him a child soldier. The SCC ruled that the government violated his s.7 charter rights when they questioned him after torture as well as refusing to bring him back to Canada. I will take The SCC's view over a random users opinion.

Omar was a child soldier brought over there by his parents. The evidence used to convict him was unreliable since it was gained through torture and lack of witnesses. His legal rights violated for 10 years as he had no trial when he was first taken in.