Jump to content

Ford era begins in Toronto


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 504
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

The odd thing is that Ford is pushing for ostensibly more expensive changes for transit, while Miller's plan was smaller and more practical.

But, hey, let's keep arguing the stereotypes.

I voted for a leftish 3rd party candidate, but I refuse to be pessimistic about the new mayor until he starts doing things that give me cause to be.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The odd thing is that Ford is pushing for ostensibly more expensive changes for transit, while Miller's plan was smaller and more practical.

But, hey, let's keep arguing the stereotypes.

Nothing odd about it. Ford's platform showed him to have almost no grasp on fiscal matters: why would transit be any different?

I voted for a leftish 3rd party candidate, but I refuse to be pessimistic about the new mayor until he starts doing things that give me cause to be.

The fact that he doesn't appear to know what he's doing and may actually be mayor in name only is prettty alarming, is it not?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The fact that he doesn't appear to know what he's doing and may actually be mayor in name only is prettty alarming, is it not?

Not really. The last two US presidents were fairly unqualified for the job, but they had their strengths. If Ford listens at the right times, to the right people he could walk that line.

I always vote left-of-centre, but I wouldn't be surprised if there was indeed a 'gravy train' somewhere... dripping gravy...

I probably won't ever, ever vote for him, but if he lays off the most at-risk citizens, and doesn't cut core services and manages to get a subway funded and planned I will at least be impressed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://www.thestar.com/news/article/902903--don-cherry-rips-left-wing-pinkos-at-council-inaugural?bn=1

“Put that in your pipe you left-wing kooks,” hockey commentator Don Cherry told a shocked inaugural meeting of the new city council, blasting “left-wing pinkos.”

Cherry was Mayor Rob Ford’s pick for a “special guest” for the pomp-filled ceremony. Cherry turned up in a pink-and-white silk jacket and patterned tie that was eye-popping even for the famously flamboyant TV star.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cherry, like our resident troll Shady, doesn't even fucking live in Toronto. It's like the further you get from the core, the dumber people get.

Aww, somebody's still upset that the vast majority of Torontonians rejected the small core of know-it-alls who think they're allowed to govern by decree.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmm I dunno much about Toronto but looking at a map of its Subway system gives me the impression that it has less routes and stations and less ridership than for example the Montreal Metro. Given Toronto's higher population, this cursory analysis would suggest that Toronto needs a major expansion of its Subway system to be competitive with Canada's other major cities in this regard.

As for streetcars.. they are an obsolete technology belonging to the 19th century. The point of urban rail transit is to get people around quickly, and to reduce traffic on the streets. Street cars traveling on streets do not get around quickly, since they physically move slowly, must wait in traffic and at lights, and they do not reduce street traffic since they travel on the streets. They do not seem to hold any particular advantage over buses (besides reduced energy use), in fact, they have many disadvantages, such as the need for additional infrastructure and the inability to adapt their routes in case of accidents or weather conditions. In contrast, systems like Skytrain and Subways can move unimpeded by lights at speeds of up to 90 km/h, moving people around the city very quickly and reducing street traffic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

….

Street cars traveling on streets do not get around quickly, since they physically move slowly, must wait in traffic and at lights, and they do not reduce street traffic since they travel on the streets.

Typically, subway stations are two kms apart from each other. So unless a patron lives within 1km of a station, he or she is likely to get there either by car or by bus. If he gets to the subway station by car, he’s (and the subway plan is) not helping to ease traffic. And furthermore, he’s going to need a place to park his vehicle at a price. Currently the parking lots along the Sheppard subway line are closed to subway patrons during rush hour – makes sense, huh?

Secondly, if he takes the bus to the station, he’s going by a surface route which is what the Transit City already is.

Bus and streetcar stops are typically at every street block or two. These surface services are much more accessible to a lot of patrons than subway stations. A bus would take the patron to the subway station, but the streetcar would take the patron to his destination. And because of their ease of accessibility, patrons can easily visit businesses along the way. And because of their ease of accessibility, most patrons won’t need to drive to the streetcar stop. A streetcar carrying 100 riders can represent 100 cars off the road. That's one streetcar waiting at a traffic light instead of 50 to 100 additional automobiles doing the same thing.

Replacing Transit City with subways is not a km-by-km comparison. Subways cost 3x more than the Transit City plan. Building a subway would in fact reduce the geographic area of service and thus reduce the impact it would have on mitigating traffic congestion simply because its routes would be 1/3 that of the planned Transit City routes. Imagine replacing 50kms of service for 17kms.

And of course there's the wasted money for work already done and the impending penalties. Not a good start for a Mayor who is supposed to be a penny pincher.

Edited by daniel
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bus and streetcar stops are typically at every street block or two. These surface services are much more accessible to a lot of patrons than subway stations. A bus would take the patron to the subway station, but the streetcar would take the patron to his destination. And because of their ease of accessibility, patrons can easily visit businesses along the way. And because of their ease of accessibility, most patrons won’t need to drive to the streetcar stop. A streetcar carrying 100 riders can represent 100 cars off the road. That's one streetcar waiting at a traffic light instead of 50 to 100 additional automobiles doing the same thing.

What does a streetcar do that a bus or two cannot? If what is needed is just more surface transit that stops frequently at convenient locations, simply increasing bus service seems like all that would be needed. If the goal is rapid transit with high ridership between high density hubs, then some type of light rail is needed. Obviously subways aren't meant to go everywhere where buses do, they are meant to go between locations where there is high enough demand to make them economically viable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Typically, subway stations are two kms apart from each other. So unless a patron lives within 1km of a station, he or she is likely to get there either by car or by bus. If he gets to the subway station by car, he’s (and the subway plan is) not helping to ease traffic.

Off course he is. His car trip is shortened.

Secondly, if he takes the bus to the station, he’s going by a surface route which is what the Transit City already is.

But his surface clogging travel is still shortened...

Bus and streetcar stops are typically at every street block or two. These surface services are much more accessible to a lot of patrons than subway stations. A bus would take the patron to the subway station, but the streetcar would take the patron to his destination.

That's quite the assumption. I take the streetcar to the subway, and given that most streetcars connect to subways, I assume I am not alone...

And because of their ease of accessibility, patrons can easily visit businesses along the way.

There is no difference between the subway or streetcar in this example.

And because of their ease of accessibility, most patrons won’t need to drive to the streetcar stop.

A streetcar carrying 100 riders can represent 100 cars off the road. That's one streetcar waiting at a traffic light instead of 50 to 100 additional automobiles doing the same thing.

On my way home, I have to take the subway to catch a streetcar...unfortunately, I often have to wait for the 3rd streetcar 'cause the first two were sardine cans..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Reading Cherry's speech, I had to wonder: is the man brain damaged? There's hardly a single coherent sentence in there. "But again, I was asked why I was asked. And I asked Doug, Rob, why?... And I could go on right now, all the millions and thousands of dollars he's gonna save and everything..." I used to look forward to Cherry on Coach's Corner; but, man, I think he's gone senile.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmm I dunno much about Toronto but looking at a map of its Subway system gives me the impression that it has less routes and stations and less ridership than for example the Montreal Metro. Given Toronto's higher population, this cursory analysis would suggest that Toronto needs a major expansion of its Subway system to be competitive with Canada's other major cities in this regard.

Toronto's subway system is by far the largest subway system in Canada. Bloor-Yonge station sees 500,000 people pass through it per day. The TTC as a whole on a regular business day carries upwards of 2 million people.

I think the subway needs an extension, but I don't think there needs to be a Sheppard extension. The Sheppard subway is already a subway to no where. It doesn't need anymore stations into Scarborough. If anything, it should be extended west so it'll connect with the Spadina section of the YUS line but even that is a tough sell.

As for other lines, what Toronto needs is the Downtown Relief Line. A wider U shaped line that will circle up from union to Dundas West and to Pape in the east. In the future, a line under Eglinton may make sense but considering bus traffic along Eglinton, a subway isn't anywhere close to being warranted.

As for streetcars.. they are an obsolete technology belonging to the 19th century. The point of urban rail transit is to get people around quickly, and to reduce traffic on the streets. Street cars traveling on streets do not get around quickly, since they physically move slowly, must wait in traffic and at lights, and they do not reduce street traffic since they travel on the streets. They do not seem to hold any particular advantage over buses (besides reduced energy use), in fact, they have many disadvantages, such as the need for additional infrastructure and the inability to adapt their routes in case of accidents or weather conditions. In contrast, systems like Skytrain and Subways can move unimpeded by lights at speeds of up to 90 km/h, moving people around the city very quickly and reducing street traffic.

Streetcars are great. I still take them every time I'm downtown. They're as fast as cars downtown and when they're placed on dedicated lines with no car traffic impeding them, they'll be faster than cars.

Edited by nicky10013
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Tell a friend

    Love Repolitics.com - Political Discussion Forums? Tell a friend!
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      10,712
    • Most Online
      1,403

    Newest Member
    nyralucas
    Joined
  • Recent Achievements

    • Jeary earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Venandi went up a rank
      Apprentice
    • Gaétan earned a badge
      Very Popular
    • Dictatords earned a badge
      First Post
    • babetteteets earned a badge
      One Year In
  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...